MINELREL-L Archive (10052001-15:33:48-29766)

Fwd: RFE/RL: Bureaucracy Creates Obstacles to Emigration of Russians from Kazahstan


Reply-To: [email protected]
Sender: [email protected]
From: MINELRES moderator <[email protected]>
Date: Fri, 5 Oct 2001 15:33:46 +0300 (EEST)
Message-Id: <[email protected]>
Subject: Fwd: RFE/RL: Bureaucracy Creates Obstacles to Emigration of Russians from Kazahstan


From: MINELRES moderator <[email protected]>

Original sender: Petra Kovacs <[email protected]>

Fwd: RFE/RL: Bureaucracy Creates Obstacles to Emigration of
Russians from Kazahstan


RFE/RL NEWSLINE Vol. 5, No. 187, Part I, 3 October 2001
END NOTE
 
BUREAUCRACY CREATES OBSTACLES TO EMIGRATION OF RUSSIANS FROM
KAZAKHSTAN
 
By Nonna Chernyakova and Russell Working
 
When Valentina Nikitina came to the gates of the Russian Embassy in
Almaty seeking citizenship, she was hoping to quickly fill out the
forms necessary to immigrate to the Russian Federation, where she has
relatives in Altai Krai. But others waiting told her that there are
more than 2,000 people on the list, and it will take up to four years
before she can pack her bags for Russia.

Nikitina's family is among the 5 million ethic Russians who make up a
third of Kazakhstan's population. They are typical of the 20 million
Russians living throughout the former Soviet republics of Central
Asia. Cut off from their ancestral homeland by the breakup of the
Soviet Union a decade ago, many now want to emigrate. But although the
Kremlin says these potential immigrants would help offset Russia's
shrinking population, officials have entangled would-be migrants in a
thicket of red tape and worn down their resolve with endless delays.

Yet those tactics run contrary to the wishes of applicants and the
stated goals of the federal government. And those wishing to immigrate
to Russia suffer from unemployment, poverty, and sometimes overt
discrimination.

For generations, Russia has been gripped by a growing demographic
crisis. The Soviet Union lost an estimated 20 million lives in World
War II. Tens of millions perished in Stalin's gulag camps. More
recently, the falling standard of living, a high abortion rate and an
increasing number of one-child families has left the Russian
Federation with a population that is falling by some 2,500 people per
day.

Russian officials say they are trying to reverse that trend.
Aleksander Blokhin, the minister for federation affairs,
nationalities, and migration, said in July that President Vladimir
Putin has approved a plan to attract ethnic Russians from neighboring
countries. Blokhin said some 4 million ethnic Russians in the former
Soviet republics are now seeking to immigrate, and perhaps as many as
20 million could be encouraged to do so in the future.

But Blokhin appeared to be unaware that many would-be immigrants are
discouraged by Russian officialdom itself. In Almaty, applicants must
line up outside for months in the hot sun or subzero cold before they
are even allowed to enter the embassy with their papers. Many feel the
Russian Embassy in Kazakhstan has ignored Blokhin's ministry's plan.
In August, no citizenships were granted, applicants complained.

Individual predicaments sometimes read like parodies of Russian
bureaucracy. Flyora Azhnakina, 56, became a Russian citizen in 1995,
but officials forgot to put a stamp in her son's birth certificate.
The boy has turned 14, and now she can't take him to Russia.

"Now they say he should become a Kazakh citizen first, when he turns
16, and then change it to Russian citizenship," she complained. "So
we'll have to sit here for four years."

Even Russian citizens have trouble helping relatives stranded abroad.
Galina Saratovtseva, a Moscow resident, came to Almaty to help her
only remaining relative obtain Russian citizenship. Her uncle,
82-year-old Ivan Shevchenko, is a World War II veteran and an invalid
who has lived in Kazakhstan since 1948. She has spent four months
gathering his papers.

"I want to take him with me because here in Kazakhstan nobody cares
about war veterans," Saratovtseva said. "All the benefits they had
before have been cancelled. My uncle fell down in the market and broke
his legs, and for three weeks he couldn't get medical help. Only his
neighbors came and helped him."

The Russian Embassy wasn't much help, either. The law states that
citizenship might be granted for special merits, "but they told me
that being a war veteran is not a special merit," Saratovtseva said.

Vyacheslav, a 28-year-old driver who asked that his last name not be
used, decided to leave Kazakhstan because all his relatives have
already left for Moscow and he doesn't think life will improve for
Russians in Kazakhstan. "I've got the impression that this year, more
Russians have left than in the last five years," he said. "All because
there are no jobs."

Tsarist troops first conquered Kazakhstan in the early 1700s, and by
1959 Russians, Ukrainians, and Belorussians made up over half the
population. The emigration of Russians started in earnest in 1993,
soon after the fall of the Soviet Union, and reached its peak the next
year, when 300,000 Russians left. In 1998-99, about 250,000 left each
year, officials say. The Russian Migration Service estimates that 2
million Russian have left Kazakhstan, though the real numbers may be
higher.

One of the most pressing reasons for the mass emigration of Russians
from Kazakhstan is the status of the Russian language, applicants say.
While Kazakh is preserved as the state language, there is no law
granting Russian any official status. While most Kazakhs also speak
Russian, the list of government professions and positions for which
Kazakh is required grows every year. Since the start of 2000, the
government has required that all office work be conducted in Kazakh.

Another obstacle for Russian workers in Kazakhstan is the rebirth of
conservative Islam there, particularly for Russian women, according to
ethnographer V.A. Tishkov. In his report, "Russians in Central Asia
and Kazakhstan," published in the Moscow journal "Studies on Applied
and Urgent Ethnology," Tishkov suggests that "Strengthening the Muslim
traditions in some Central Asian countries...will hamper the activity
of Russian teachers and artistic intelligentsia.... The spread of
Islam might reflect on the population's attitude toward women's labor.
Russian women who live in other ethnic environments are the most
vulnerable." Tishkov added that in Kazakhstan, the situation is better
for Russians where Muslim traditions are weakest, as in cities such as
Almaty.

Nevertheless, thousands of Russians are desperate and want to leave
Kazakhstan, where they lived comfortably for decades.

"I worked as an engineer in a refrigerator plant," said Nikitina. "Now
I can't find a cleaning lady's job. I am still young; I can work. But
here we live like beggars."

Nonna Chernyakova and Russell Working are freelance journalists based
in Vladivostok.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Copyright (c) 2001 RFE/RL, Inc.
All rights reserved.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

------------------- 
Addresses for the Multiethnic Group
List Moderator: [email protected]
Subscribe: [email protected]
Unsubscribe:  [email protected]
Discussion page: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/multiethnic
Multiethnic Project: http://lgi.osi.hu/ethnic/

-- 
==============================================================
MINELRES - a forum for discussion on minorities in Central&Eastern
Europe

Submissions: [email protected]  
Subscription/inquiries: [email protected] 
List archive: http://www.riga.lv/minelres/archive.htm
==============================================================